This is another post from the Suggest a Topic page, and this time we’re going to take a look at rights issues, and as the commenter put it – the fuss about them.
A rights issue is when a company issues new shares, but offers it to their existing shareholders first. The existing shareholders then have an option to either buy the new shares or pass the offer. So, recently when the SBI rights issue was in the news, it was often said that the government is willing to subscribe to the rights issue, and that’s because they own 59.4% of SBI, and if any shares are issued without the government participating in the offer then their shareholding in the company will come down.
This will be clear with an example, so let’s look at the latest rights issue – that of Velan Hotels Limited. They are issuing 2,67,35,500 (2.67 cr) new shares as part of the rights issue at Rs. 23 per share, and the ratio is 69:20.
69:20 means that for every 20 shares that you currently own – you can subscribe up to 69 new shares. The rationale for this seemingly weird allocation ratio will be clear in a minute.
The number of outstanding shares in the company before the rights issue were 77,50,000 and when you add the 2,67,35,500 new shares to the existing shares you get a total of 3,44,87,500 shares.
|Equity shares prior to the issue||Â 77,50,000.00|
|New Shares to be issued||Â 2,67,37,500.00|
|Total shares after the issue||Â 3,44,87,500.00|
Now, when you divide the number of new shares to be issued (2,67,37,500) by the number of equity shares prior to the issue (77,50,000) you get 3.45.
Guess what you get whenÂ you divide 69 by 20?
Exactly right – you get 3.45.
Now do you see where the weird ratio of 69:20 come from?
If the rights issue is offered in that ratio and if all existing shareholders subscribe fully to the rights issue then their ownership in the company will remain exactly the same as it was before the issue.
The issue of new shares doesn’t dilute their ownership in the company at all!
This will be clearer if we look at how the promoter stake changes in this issue with the rights issue, and what would have happened if there weren’t a rights issue, and a simple IPO to issue shares.
Before this issue, the promoters owned 56.35% of Velan Hotels, which means they had 43,67,426 shares in all.
|Promoters own||Â 43,67,426.00|
|Equity shares prior to the issue||Â 77,50,000.00|
Suppose this were a FPO or a fresh issue of shares, and the promoters didn’t subscribe to the fresh issue in the FPO. If that were to happen then the promoters will only own 12.66% of the company as seen from the numbers below.
|Promoters Own||Â 43,67,426.00|
|Total shares including the new ones||Â 3,44,87,500.00|
As you can see that would not be a good scenario for the promoters, and in fact other shareholders also. Their existing shareholding will be diluted by quite a bit.
However, the ratio of 69:20 means that the promoters by virtue of their 43,67,426 will have the option to buy 1,50,67,620 additional shares (43,67,426 x 3.45), and take the total shares they own to 1,94,35,046, which is 56.35% of the new total outstanding shares, and thus the rights issue doesn’t affect their ownership in the company at all.
|Promoters Own||Â 4,367,426.00|
|Additional shares they can buy (3.45 times current holding)||Â 15,067,620|
|Total shares they own||Â 19,435,046|
|Total number of shares after the issue||34487500|
|Promoter stake in the company after the rights issue||56.35%|
The fuss is essentially about retaining the same ownership in the company even after the issue of fresh issue of shares.
For small shareholders – the issue of ownership control doesn’t arise, but the earnings per share will reduce since there are now more shares for the same earnings, and so will the dividends so whenever a company comes out with a rights issue you have to evaluate it to see whether it makes sense for you to subscribe or if you are better off with getting rid of the existing position or should you do nothing at all. Right now I’m unable to think of any factors that need to be considered apart from of course the financial situation of the company, and the price at which the rights issue is being offered but if we ever discuss a live rights issue in the future, we will weigh in on those factors then.
The last thing about subscribing to the rights issue is that you can choose to subscribe to all of the shares you are eligible for, or a part of them. If you don’t do anything then no new shares will be subscribed to you.
The procedure to apply for new shares is that they send in a form to your address, and you have to fill in your details and submit that form to a collection center before the last date. You have to follow this process even if you do everything else online – to the best of my knowledge this process hasn’t been made online yet.
So, to summarize, rights issue is when a company issues fresh shares, but offers them to their existing shareholders in a pre determined ratio first. The existing shareholders can subscribe to these shares, and that helps them own the company in the same percentage that they did prior to the fresh issue.